TotalTelly.co.uk

Devoted to Popular, Cult and Retro TV

Manderlay [2005]


RRP: £19.99
Our Price: £6.49 (subject to change)

Great sequel
Review date: 2008-03-20 Rating: 10 out of 10

Frankly most people have turned off Dogville within twenty minutes.I almost did myself.If you are onto Manderlay it is more of the same.I prefer Dogville but thought both were excellent, they are up there as a pair in my top twenty.The style takes a while to get used to but like a subtitled film it's the story, of Rose (?) that takes over and it soon becomes an irrelevance, the staging that is .The efforts of the innocent to improve the lot of others.Both films are heavy with the feeling that the story on screen is not the message that the film is trying to put across however both films stand up without third party explanations.I heard recently there is to be a third which makes me think the films are either cheap to produce ie)the actors receive a small fee or someone at the studio likes them a lot.

Definitely try either you will not be disappointed.

Similar Products

Reviews


God bless America
Review date: 2007-11-04 Rating: 8 out of 10

Danish director Lars Von Trier continues his Deep South adventure with this fable about race, power, isolation and freedom.

Like 2003's Dogville, there is something refreshingly literal about Von Trier's screenplay. That's not to say it lacks subtext - it is abundant - but at times its political convictions are presented like a series of political soundbites. While the blank theatre-style set is perhaps not used as effectively as it was in Dogville, the technique again adds weight to the bluntness of the key polemics.

Von Trier's magic is in tackling weighty subject matter in a very watchable way. Dancer In The Dark, for example, probably his most powerful deconstruction of the American Dream, showed us a new twist on the classical Hollywood musical; and without patronising its heritage it made a pertinent political point. Like that masterpiece, Manderlay demands the audience leave their expectations at the door whilst offering a reasonably straightforward narrative containing some satisfying plot twists and a surprising amount of dark humour. It may be less genre-specific than Dancer In The Dark, but like all this ex-Dogme director's latter films, it is accessible, neat and tight, and fleet of foot.

Von Trier presents yet another spiky woman-in-peril. Bryce Dallas Howard takes over from Nicole Kidman as the idealistic Grace. She turns out to be the ideal choice, too - there's a broadness to the shoulders and a steeliness to the eyes of this stronger, wiser heroine. Those who have Von Trier marked down as a misogynist will be pleased (or possibly disappointed) to hear that this troubled heroine is his most powerful and least set-upon to date. John Hurt, Chloe Sevigny, Jeremy Davies, Udo Kier, Lauren Bacall and Von Trier regular Jean-Marc Barr all return for another round of selfless bit parts.

Those concerned with the idea of watching a movie without a set shouldn't worry - it's practically unnoticeable after a time, thanks largely to the quality and intensity of the drama. This is classy, intelligent film-making from a talented and consistent auteur.

annoyed!
Review date: 2007-09-30 Rating: 2 out of 10

i was soo annoyed because i picked up this dvd and read the synopsis and it sounded really good and interesting, and then started to watch it and was just repulsed, i coundn't watch the film at all and turned it off after about 1o minutes due to the way it was filmed.ive seen many films but not one like this. it was done on a stage with stupid theatre props, and very view props, so it looked very bare and dull.i was shocked because it seemed so unrealistic and just horrible. never again!

phenomenal...but limited appeal
Review date: 2007-01-15 Rating: 8 out of 10

A real shame that von Treier's feels the need to intellectualise his films with this theatrical setting. Even the film buffs I know arent convinced by it and the general populous who should be watching this film will be instantly turned off.
This is an amazing story. I would have rather read the book or watched a 'real' film.
Amazing how relevant it is to the freedom we are 'giving/forcing on' Iraq at the moment...
Watch and squirm!

'puerile'??? no, no, no
Review date: 2006-08-16 Rating: 10 out of 10

Some say 'puerile', some say 'sardonic' or a 'wind-up', but Manderlay is none of the above. It is an acutely achieved masterpiece and one of the most intelligent pieces of cinema of the decade.

The film is based on the paradoxes involved when one group attempts to impose philosophies on others, philosophies that are blinded to the power relationships that bind any socio-economic situation. In less jargonistic terms, it shows us the paradox when we say freedom for all yet that freedom enables consequences we don't like.

Grace sees an atrocity, in a liberal-minded spirit she attempts to solve the atrocity by bringing freedom to a colony of slaves still working a cotton plantation 80 years after abolition. She preaches values of freedom and democracy and attempts to teach the slaves in these principles, installing the institution of the referendum to all decisions affecting the cotton farm they now all partly own. Conflicts then ensue on two levels, conflicts between the use of the vote and the logical call of science (they set the clock according to the vote) and conflicts between the use of the vote and the emotions of morality, the referendums result in resolutions that Grace finds repulsive to her morality.

This conflict is a demonstration of the conflict between democracy and rights based legal systems now faced in the world's liberal democracies. When the mass-opinion does not accord with the rights based consensus, the dictatorship of the legal system trumps the demos. This is fundamentally a power relationship and Trier realises this brilliantly in Grace's 'humane' shooting of an old slave who the group had condemned to a death of suffering.

The film delves into the question of when a group can be free. When one group enslaves another and frees them, they will do so on their own terms. The intricate reality of this situation is that the new order will place a number of curtailments on the substantive freedom of individuals in the group and the group itself. The only way for the group to be free would be to hold power themselves, something that has not happened to this date in the scarred continent of America.

The 'puerile' critiques of this film tend to be a knowing snarl at what Lars was doing. Yet the critics who put them forward fail to see that he, however ironically, poses philosophical questions that rarely grace the silver screen. Not only that, but philosophical questions with a political reality deeply relevant as we see with the gross inequality in the United States, the hypocritical and sanctimonious positioning of western states to developing nations, and the deeply problematic subjectivist vs objectivist dilemmas that face our western nations in our lovely 'war on terror'.

Product Details/Specifications


Actor(s):
Danny Glover
Bryce Dallas Howard
Isaach De Bankole
Willem Dafoe

Creators:
Bryce Dallas Howard (Primary Contributor)
Isaach De Bankole (Primary Contributor)

Director(s):

Recording label: Metrodome Distribution
Manufacturer: Metrodome Distribution
EAN: 5055002552557
Binding: DVD
Number of items: 1
Format: PAL,
Release date: 2006-07-03
Audience rating: Suitable for 15 years and over
Region code: 2
Running time: 133 minutes
Theatrical release date: 2005
Language: English (Original Language)

Add to Cart

© 2006 Darren Hester, DesignsByDarren.com, Some Rights Reserved.
Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional