RRP: £19.99
Our Price: £5.98 (subject to change)
Editorial
Amazon.co.uk Review
Office manager Michael Scott (Steve Carell, The Daily Show, The 40 Year-Old Virgin) believes he's the beloved leader of the Scranton, Pennsylvania, branch of a paper products company--but his relentless and painfully forced efforts at comedy creep out everyone around him, including paranoid Dwight (Rainn Wilson, who had a memorable recurring role on Six Feet Under), nervous receptionist Pam (Jenna Fischer, LolliLove), and aimless salesman Jim (John Krasinski, A New Wave), who's smitten with the already engaged Pam. The pilot episode suffers from closely replicating the British pilot, but after that The Office finds its own footing, turning diversity training, an office birthday party, and a basketball game into excruciating yet hypnotically funny rituals of humiliation. Carell, though clearly talented, can't match Ricky Gervais' unique performance as the aggressively needy British manager (it's hard to imagine that anyone could); as a result, the supporting roles become more prominent, and Wilson, Fischer, and Krasinski quickly create a rapport that matches and may even exceed that of their British counterparts. Be sure to watch the deleted scenes; remarkably, they're as good as the material that made it on the air in this six-episode season. --Bret Fetzer
Editorial
Synopsis
Based on the popular British comedy of the same name, The Office uses the same mockumentary style and humour derived from awkward social situations. However, it has managed to establish its own fan base and identity apart from the shadow of the original. At the Dunder Miffin Paper Company, manager Michael Scott believes himself beloved by his employees for his jokey nature. What he doesn't realise is that most of them resent and even despise him, except for sycophantic Dwight. Meanwhile, Jim woos engaged receptionist Pam, while both navigate the office politics and 'humour' of boss Scott. The Office may be a remake, but it has charms of its very own. Series One includes the first six episodes.
Lacks comedy talent and follows the Uk version far too closely
Review date: 2008-08-14 Rating: 4 out of 10
I love Steve Carell, I always find him great to watch, the trouble here is that he is just about the only thing worth the price of season 1.
The US version follows the UK version far too closely for my liking, the office is merging with another office, jokes are repeated (stapler in the jelly again!!).
The comedy talent in the UK version was very good, everyone regardless of how much screen time they had could do comedy very well, here Steve Carell provides at least 80% of the laughs due to the inability of most of the rest of the cast to deliver a line well and effectively.
The guy who's the equivalent to Martin Freemans character is at best okay at comedy, the equivalent of Mackenzie Crooks character is the second best comedy actor on show here, but that's not saying much as at best he's reasonably good at comedy himself, the woman that plays the receptionist is virtually useless at anything!!
These four characters were THE reason why the UK office was so good, so to have 2 no shows, one reasonable effort and only one true comedy actor amongst these four is why this effort does not begin to touch the UK version, in theory this must have gotten better as there are now 4 seasons on the US show, if I ever watch anymore of the US version then it'll have to be for free to win me over and prove that it's not just a UK Office rip off and a poor effort at that.
Overall very few positives and loads of negatives, as a show in it's own right I'd give it 3 stars, but I can't help but compare this version to the UK version, this comes in dead last in comparison, too few laughs from poor material and poor comedy actors on the whole.