TotalTelly.co.uk
Devoted to Popular, Cult and Retro TV
Tarnation
RRP: £19.99
Our Price: £3.15 (subject to change)
Fantastic
Review date: 2007-01-20 Rating: 10 out of 10
This film is a work of art. Through a variety of mediums Caouette has created something beautifully devastating. A reflection on a troubled relationship between a mother with psychological and son (Caouette). Tarnation is gripping from the start, the use of real footage entwines the you into a volatile journey, definitely worth seeing. The film also has some of the best and most appropriate use of music throughout.
Similar Products
- Capturing The Friedmans [2004]
- Elephant [2004]
- The Squid And The Whale [2005]
- Welcome To The Dollhouse [1995]
- Dark Days [2001] (REGION 1) (NTSC)
Reviews
Unique
Review date: 2006-05-04 Rating: 10 out of 10
This is a film that you don't watch for entertainment. Its a painful story that you have to absorb yourself into.
I can understand why other people might not give this film too much merit, but I have never seen such an emotionally powerful film.
Give it your attention, try and watch it, and I hope you feel the strength of realisation.
Overrated
Review date: 2006-04-13 Rating: 6 out of 10
Jonathan Caouette's highly personal film lends itself more to installational video art than to cinema or even documentary. Its frenetic visual style, using splices of camcorder and digital video footage taken over a twenty year period, often detracts from what might be of interest on camera itself. There is too much lo-fi trickery for the viewer to become especially involved in what is undeniably an extraordinary family history. This is frustrating because footage obviously exists that would be able to comprise a fantastic documentary - think of Capturing the Friedmans or Grizzly Man. But unlike those films Caouette is often preoccupied with convincing the viewer of his drug-damaged worldview (we are told he became "depersonalised" after smoking PCP) through a maddening bombardment of imagery, rather than letting the real people and emotions doing the talking.
Some of the imagery is interesting, but much of it derivative and excessive. Caouette is obviously trying to achieve something more subjectivised and abstract than a straight-forward documentary, but then the effect - as with much of the gallery-based video art it resembles - is more alienating than perhaps is intended. The more he experiments with video form, the more the content is debased to sheer spectacle. Moreover, when Caouette turns the camera on himself in the film's present - willing himself to confront his family - it seems contrived, as if he can't find a way to create closure for his film without forcing an ending. Highly overrated, and not to be confused with the current renaissance in documentary cinema (including some of the films I have mentioned above).
A fantastic but flawed achievement.
Review date: 2006-01-18 Rating: 8 out of 10
The fact that this allegedly cost around $260 dollars to make is incredible and gives great hope for the future of cinema and also great dread that any old fool with a video camera will soon be clogging up our already limited arthouse cinema screentime with their introspective woes. This is an extremely heartbreaking story of a mother possibly misdiagnosed with mental problems and subsequently driven to madness by the 'treatment'. And that is the only problem with the film. My sympathies lie firmly with the director's mother and not the director whose crying in front of camera seemed rather more self-pitying than genuine. Call me hard-hearted (you may well be right) but would someone that filled with grief really wait to set up a camera in a bathroom before breaking down in front of it? Regardless, the film deserves to be seen by as large an audience as possible.
One man's love for his mother
Review date: 2005-08-09 Rating: 10 out of 10
This really is something this film. It has taken over 20 years to put together.
Essentially a biography of a family told using photos, videos, audio recordings taken over the years.
These images and movies are cut together with a soundtrack from the likes of Low and Iron and Wine and are 'narrated' by stark overlaid text.
The film was apparently produced for next to nothing using nothing more than an iMac and it's stark simplicity simply hypnotises you.
It is the story of the film-maker (Jonathon Caouette), his mother and his grand-parents. He was raised by his grand-parents whilst his mother underwent years of barbaric treatment in psychiatric wards - all sanctioned by her parents. A terrible tale of a woman who, initially, had nothing wrong with her and was subjected to hundreds of electro-shock therapy sessions and eventually a lithium overdose. This radically changed a beautiful, ex-model into a disturbed, yet still vibrant women.
Her son shows her the kind of love that really hits home. Incredibly touching displays of his commitment to her.
Overall, it is a very sad story which warms the heart. You can not look away from the screen for a second as the perfect cadence of the film beats on. It'll upset you and make you feel great all at once. And you will ring your mother at the end of it.
Product Details/Specifications
Actor(s):
Jonathan Caouette
Creators:
Jonathan Caouette (Primary Contributor)
Director(s):
Recording label: Optimum Home Entertainment
Manufacturer: Optimum Home Entertainment
EAN: 5060034571872
Binding: DVD
Number of items: 1
Format: PAL,
Release date: 2005-07-25
Aspect ratio: 1.33:1
Audience rating: Suitable for 15 years and over
Region code: 2
Running time: 88 minutes
Theatrical release date: 2003
Language: English (Original Language)