RRP: £9.99
Our Price: £18.76 (subject to change)
Exquisite adaptation - watch it!
Review date: 2008-06-21 Rating: 10 out of 10
This video had been knocking around my local charity shop for a while, and I'd been vaguely debating whether or not to buy it. It was only £2 but I was just so tired of hammy, thespy, unsubtle adaptations of beloved books, which reduce sub-plots and characters to tokens and use completely rewritten, overly 21st century dialogue. I love the novel Tess of the D'Urbervilles, and I didn't want to see it ruined.
Just five minutes in, as soon as Justine Waddell appeared on screen, I knew this adaptation was going to do the book justice. Justine Waddell is exactly how I had pictured Tess and at the beginning exuded the simple but dignified country girl sweetness of Tess (also, she is absolutely beautiful in a natural way, just like Tess. The camera loves her). She proves to be a very skilled and subtle actress throughout Tess' trials and tribulations; compelling and heart-breaking. In her scene with Alec towards the end, there is something positively Old Hollywood about her. Her voice is an instrument well-used, too. I honestly can't imagine a better performance of Tess; what an achievement.
Her male leads don't let her down either. Oliver Milburn is wonderful as Angel Clare. Although Angel is flawed and unwittingly cruel, Oliver Milburn helps bring out his appeal (it helps that he's radiantly attractive with strawy hair and a kind voice!) so we can empathise with Tess' idealisation of him and feel his neglect even more cruelly. Watching this adaptation actually helped me to understand their relationship better, because in my reading of the book Angel had come off as rather anaemic and sexless. In the last few scenes, his idealism falls away to let his love shine through so strongly; another heartbreaking performance!
Jason Flemyng is a wonderfully repellent Alec D'Urberville, though that's not to say his performance lacks subtlety; Alec could be a pantomime villain in the wrong hands but this adaptation shows his complex character. I felt he really did love Tess, in his possessive, insensitive, immature way.
The Wessex landscape was beautiful and the depiction of country life was respectful but unsentimental; it felt real. The cinematography is gorgeous, lighting up the countryside.
Overall, it's a lot more faithful to the book than most adaptations. This makes for a long film, but there isn't a redundant scene. I especially appreciated the amount of original dialogue from the novel. I can't imagine anyone who had read and loved the book being disappointed. I think they did Thomas Hardy proud!
I realise that is most probably not an appropriate sentence to start a review with, but it is my true opinion. I appreciate fully the effort put into the movie and I can see how some people will fall in love with the film. The amount of struggles young Tess Durbeyfield (played by Justine Waddell) goes through are heart wrenching, and in various parts of the movie you are gripped by an urge to try and shake her to her senses. But it seems that fate has decided that Tess will walk the hard road through life. From a young and ripe age, Tess faces the brutal reality of the world, and goes through experiences that are to leave her scarred forever and shape her future.
The film starts portraying Tess's family poverty and difficulties. On the day of the May dance, Tess's father discovers that he is a lineal descendant of the D'Urberville family. Tess is a bashful girl, reluctant between helping her family, which is her responsibility, or finding her own happiness. As her harsh life drags on, she chooses to support her family.
She goes to work for some relatives. There she meets Alec U'Urberville (Jason Flemyng), a distant cousin who is very taken with her. One night, he takes her by force and when she looses her innocence she is never quite the same again. Alec proposes after the act, but as she does not love him, she refuses. She becomes pregnant, and her child dies, shunned by most. If she had married Alec, she could have lived in a beautiful Victorian mansion complete with wood floors and ferns in planters on pedestals. This enormous wealth is hard to refuse, seeing and living in the extreme poverty amongst her family.
A while after the death of her child, whom she Christians Sorrow, she leaves home once again to work in a farm. After her forced submission with Alec, we are led to believe that she will never love again. However, at this farm, she falls in love with Angle Clare (Oliver Milburn), whom all the other milkmaids also love. Angel falls in love with her, too, and pursues her for her hand in marriage. After numerous 'maybes' and gentle rebukes, they share a kiss and she finally agrees. However, her dark secret is eating her up, and is the reason for her initial declination.
On the night of their marriage, Tess writes a letter explaining to Angel all she had gone through, despite her mother's warnings. However, she quickly seizes it quickly back before Angel has a chance to read it. They marry the next day, and the crowing crow tells us Tess's misfortunes have not ended...
Will she confess all to Angel on their wedding night? What will happen if she does follow her heart and tell her lover all that is troubling her? This movie does leave you wanting to know how it ends with Tess... and you follow through her entire life in the three hours - that, to be honest, drag. Perhaps Ian Sharp (director) intended this, for Tess's life dragged, but that did not lessen my desire for the movie to be over. I felt it wrenching my heart and my fists clenched numerous times throughout the movie.
The viewer does wish that she had changed some of her decisions, the ones that seem so unbelievably stupid. However, who are we to judge? We did not go through what she did - most of her actions that followed were a sign of her desperation and suffering. I conclude that this is a movie I definitely do not wish to set eyes on again, never again see the sufferings of a young woman unnecessary. After a certain point in the movie I just feel that the Thomas Hardy hated Tess and wished to bestow upon her every evil he could think of. This would not be a movie I would watching again... I can think of many other things to do in three hours a lot more worth my while.