RRP: £5.99
Our Price: £1.76 (subject to change)
Disappointing - Review contains details of the movie!
Review date: 2008-01-15 Rating: 2 out of 10
I was a big fan of BTB's Emma Harte triology (OK, now 6 books) - with are all fantastic! The Woman of Substance film was great, it followed the plot of the book reasonably well. However, I found the third installment most disappointing, as it greatly deviates from, and even cheapens, the premise of the third novel.
The story of the film is much different from the book, and not in the usual book-to-movie amendments that would be expected. Alexander Barkstone has been made into a bumbling fool who contributes to the weakening the Hartes stores through an "un-Sandy like" trait of excessive gambling, Shane O'Neill is a territorial, arrogant, dominant male who now begrudges his wife's work (and his hotels have become a 'middling' concern), and her brother Philip O'Neill is a chauvinist pig. The story line of the novel was replaced with fist-fights and gunplay as would be expected in a third rate Bond movie without gadgets or fun toys, and very unnecessarily so. There was a suicide, the injuring of a child through rampaging horses, assassination attempt, and two murders (I know - wrong book to base this movie on!!). The story focuses on Jonathan Ainsleys masterminding of Paula O'Neils downfall - while he is tricky in the book by buying Hartes shares he is more opportunistic and not the puppet master. There is no mention of Emily or the Kallinskis - the role of Ronald Kallinski instead taken on by Hartes head of security played by Anthony Hopkins (although in a more cloak-and-dagger manner and always good for added sexual tension), and cousin Sarah is back on the scene with a bitchy vengance. And what on earth is going on with Paulas hair??
While I understand the need for simplifying the story I dont feel that there was any need to deviate as far from the book as this film has. Its almost like it was rewritten to entertain the boys who are watching by proxy - though it fails in that as well! In summary, I was very disappointed as it could have been a much more entertaining film. While the acting and casting was passable, and the locations realistic, the plot leaves very much to be desired.