The movie rattles through all the clichés: bugs in phones; cars that cruise ominously by; staged road accidents; night-time intrusions; mystery men who hand out clues in the supermarket; dubious polygraph results; appearing and disappearing witnesses; smugly brutal generals, brilliantly made points of law; fights in the interview room; multiple revelations; a media circus and a final tussle in a darkened, deserted house. Judd, one of the best screen actresses of her generation, needs to pick better scripts since her commitment to rubbish only makes her look silly, but Freeman has done enough of these walk-through parts to get by on charisma and the odd smart line. On the DVD: High Crimes on disc comes with a gaggle of featurettes: a chat with the author of the original novel, Joseph Finder, some making-of puffery about staging stunts and the working relationship of the stars, and interesting little bits with the technical advisors about the court martial system and how to beat a polygraph. Franklin contributes a commentary track with a lot of enthusiasm, which is a little more pleased with the end product than most viewers will be. --Kim Newman
RRP: £12.99
Our Price: £3.55 (subject to change)
Editorial
Amazon.co.uk Review
Just about acceptable as an in-flight movie, High Crimes is a tad weak for the big-screen, though its amiable stars and typical plotting offer the comforts of familiarity for home viewing. Ashley Judd plays a high-end lawyer who specialises in brilliant defence of the guilty, while Morgan Freeman is a broken-down ex-drunk who specialises in court martials ("military justice is to justice what military music is to music"). When Judd's handyman husband (Jim Caviezel) is arrested by the FBI and indicted for a massacre carried out in El Salvador while he was serving as a marine, Judd gets over the fact that he has concealed his entire past and even his real name and rallies to fight the case, even if it means going up against the shadowy masters of a conspiracy to cover up what actually happened.
Tepid middle of the road thriller with nothing new to offer
Review date: 2008-02-18 Rating: 4 out of 10
Before you've seen a frame of this film you've already seen it. It follows a set pattern/formula and doesn't even bother coming up with an interesting twist from out of left field to justify its existence.
If you're actively seeking out an average middle of the road thriller then you should like it. If you're wanting something good then don't waste your time on this. I expected it to be deeply unremarkable so I'm not disappointed as I got exactly what I was expecting.
If the film had a few more "action" scenes (by action I mean scenes of jeopardy), better drawn characters and a more imaginative ending then I would give it three stars. As it is I found it to be slightly boring and it leaned a bit too heavily on obvious cliches. Put it this way, it's not a film that challenges your preconceptions.
Claire Kubrik (Ashley Judd) is a high powered attorney who though she knew everything about her husband, Tom, until he is arrested for crimes he committed in El Salvador, whilst a member of a Special Forces detachment.
Claire vows to defend her husband, but being uninitiated in military law she recruits ex-marine Charlie Grimes (Morgan Freeman) to her cause. For all his legal knowledge, Grimes has a reputation for being something of a loose cannon and a reformed alcoholic to boot.
And this is where you get the feeling you’ve seen it all before, although its rather well shot and some of the action scenes are well presented you do feel that the direction is running to a script.
That’s not to say that Judd and Freeman don’t generate some good atmosphere between themselves and you get the feeling that they are obviously enjoying the experience of the film. Both put in good solid performances (as you would expect) and they try to get as much from their roles as possible. There’s not much in the way of support, especially from Jim Caviezel (as Claire’s husband) but both Adam Scott and Amanda Peet put in some great turns with more than a little sweet romance.
Don’t expect anything new here, but this is never the less a good solid thriller adventure film and is well worth checking out.
I am a great fan of Ashley Judd and I have enjoyed most of her films (Double Jeopardy, Kiss the Girls) and I was over-all pleased with High Crimes. The plot twists up and down and really keeps you guessing. Although it may have a few clichés (Bugged Phones, Corrupt Officials), High Crimes really did impress me. Morgan Freeman gave a so-so performance, with quite a few good lines. Overall, a decent thriller with a twisting plot.