RRP: £15.99
Our Price: £3.48 (subject to change)
a lacklustre story but it keeps the viewer watching for its duration
Review date: 2008-06-03 Rating: 6 out of 10
I'm a fan of Woody Allen films because they're always laced with witty comment and insight into the human condition.This film is no exception but I found that unlike many of Allen's other films the narrative didn't seem to focus enough on anyone in particular (which is surprising given the emphasis on Hannah in the film's title)and that I didn't feel emotionally involved or sympathetic towards any of the characters being portrayed.
Michael Caine's character seemed out of place (an englishman in New York).
I also found the old-fashioned 1930s music and 1930s reminiscent drab,colourless clothes of the cast out of place given that we were supposed to be experiencing New York in the 1980s.However the dialogue was in general good and the film locations interesting.From watching other Woody Allen films I've noticed that they are at their best when he's in them and when he focuses the story on one particular actress.If you watch Melinda and Melinda you'll see an acting performance from Radha Mitchell -who plays Melinda -that is far superior to any performance by an actress in Hannah and her Sisters and likewise in Mighty Aphrodite - in my opinion Woody's best film - a tremendous and oscar winning performance from Mira Sorvino whose interaction with Woody is believable and hilarious and makes you like both Woody's character and her own.Hannah and her Sisters won three oscars overall but don't let this fact and the impressive cast fool you - it is by no means Woody Allen's greatest work.I suspect that the film got its oscars more for its political take on the idea that family units are full of plotting and intrigue and not any better than alternative kinds of relationships,and that if people love each other it doesn't matter what harm their actions may cause (they're only human afterall and the rest of us are really this bad too),rather than for the real quality of the script ( the story plodded on a bit and was even a little disjointed) or the acting
( Michael Caine's performance in particular was awkward and seemed out of place but he received an oscar for best supporting actor!).
For some reason, Woody's movies never get the full DVD treatment, and here we receive no narratives, documentaries or interviews. The DVD menu is bland and cheaply done. We are not even offered Dolby sound, though I concede that the movie was originally recorded in mono. What we do get is the movie, dubbed in five languages (English, German, French, Spanish and Italian) and theatrical trailer.
Woody is an important figure in cinema but not huge box-office. That may explain why MGM lavishes so little attention on the DVDs of his work.
Allen plays Mickey Sachs, a troubled television producer struggling with the question of the meaning of life. A series of experiences lead him to try and find his 'higher truth,' in the same inimitable and hilarious style portrayed in so many of Allen's films. Artistic and philosophical anecdotes and queries are applied relevantly and humourously, making the viewer laugh as well as ponder.
Mickey's ex-wife Hannah is played brilliantly by Mia Farrow, and the cast is completed by a host of other great names including Michael Caine, Barbara Hershey, Dianne Wiest, Carrie Fisher and, one of Allen's favourites, Julie Kavner. The film focuses intently on the theme of reality: the lives of three ordinary sisters, the ones they love, and the lengths taken to keep the peace and help each other: but not without a few mishaps on the way. The integration of Allen's character and the sisters is brought together at the end in a way the viewer could never expect.
With a musical score including music by McCarthy-Monaco and Cahn-Styne, and references to artists and poets such as E.E Cummings cleverly applied, 'Hannah and her Sisters' really is Woody at his best.
The acting is breathtakingly intense, the structure of the film is professionally carried through to perfection, and the threads just fit together in a beautiful symphony of life!
It really is hard to describe something this well-done, so instead I will just recommend you to see this wonderful Woody Allen creation.