RRP: £17.99
Editorial
Amazon.co.uk Review
The Disney touch is all over this grand, colourful version of the Johann Wyss adventure of a European family setting off for the new world of New Guinea. The film opens on a ship jostled and torn by a raging storm while a family struggles to make it through alive. Tossed into a reef near a deserted tropical island, father John Mills takes charge and the family soon turns their island prison into a veritable paradise. Their multi-level tree house, built in record time, is complete with running water and a working pipe organ scavenged from the ship, while their grand yard is abloom in English roses. As a tale of hardship and pioneer pluck it's pure fantasy, but as entertainment it's energetic and appealing. The island is impossibly populated by ostriches, zebras, lions and elephants, a private zoo that delights the youngest boy and offers plenty of comic relief. The two older brothers discover even wilder life when they rescue the prisoner of oriental pirates (led by hard-bitten Sessue Hayakawa). There's little real danger anywhere in the film: even the climactic battle with the pirates is a cartoonish affair, with coconut bombs and non-lethal booby traps, until the final desperate, deadly moments. Hardly a faithful adaptation of the novel, but a lush, beautifully shot film and an entertaining adventure safe for all ages. Dorothy McGuire co-stars as the proper, worry-prone mother. --Sean Axmaker
A great family adventure film - but get the 2-disc NTSC version
Review date: 2008-11-28 Rating: 10 out of 10
Walt Disney's hugely expensive adaptation of the classic tale of a family of castaways on a desert island maintains enough of a running thread not to seem too episodic even if it does drag a tad in places. There's not much sense of danger, despite the fact that the anaconda James MacArthur and Tommy Kirk wrestle with in one sequence turns out to be real - this is far too wholesome for that. The Robinsons are very much Disney's idea of the ideal All-American sixties family: the girls don't get to have any fun, unless you count girly stuff like dancing. Some of the animal scenes are a bit worrying 30 years on (such as the Great Danes attacking the tiger) and Kevin Corcoran is plain annoying, but for all that it remains an entertainingly old-fashioned adventure story.
While the UK and European PAL releases typically boast no extras whatsoever, the 2-disc NTSC `Vault Disney' release is as handsome a package as you are ever likely to see and can be heartily recommended to all fans of the film.
Aside from an audio commentary with director Annakin, Tommy Kirk, James MacArthur and Kevin Corcoran, the copious extra fatures include an 18-minute cutdown of the 1940 version of Swiss Family Robinson, featurettes, storyboard-to-film comparison, 6 radio spots, radio story album, stills galleries, original location scouting reports, script extract, the original theatrical trailer and TV spot. But the highlight (or lowlight, depending on your point of view) of the supplementaries is the 'Swiss Family Robinson Calypso' in a 28-minute extract from an episode of 'Disneyland' devoted to the making of the film -
'Yes my friends we had a lot of fun,
Making Swiss Family Robin-sun,
Yes my friends we had a lot of fun,
Spending Walt Dis-i-ney's five mill-i-un.'
Uncle Walt himself, resplendent in brylcream, begs to differ - it was actually $4,518,000, but heck, that wouldn't rhyme (the calypso was actually released to cinemas as a promotional single). If it would have been nice to have seen more of the programme, it does include fascinating footage of the hurricane that hit the crew in the middle of filming one of the raft sequences.
Highly recommended - the NTSC version, that is!
This movie has a great family feel to it and I really liked the animal races; it is a classic Disney. The pirate attack scene was suspenseful. You are kept wondering if, and how they will get out of it.
You can see John Mills play a more serious side with his real daughter Hayley Mills in "The Chalk Garden" (1964).